Balboa Island Reserve

Hand crafted since 2017

The Store

Learn More

Balboa Island Reserve began as a conversation about what was missing. Not another cigar shop. A place built on restraint, intention, and the understanding that time is the only luxury that matters.

Every wrapper is chosen for character. Every blend is aged for balance, not force. Every seal is measured for integrity.

This is not for everyone. And that is precisely the intention.

Balboa Island Reserve cigar shop storefront on Marine Avenue, Balboa Island, California
Lady on a Horse - Founder of Balboa Island Cigar Co. enjoying a premium cigar

Our Philosophy

A cigar is not consumed. It is approached with attention. The cut matters. The light matters. The first draw sets the tone. The second deepens it.

We teach this at our complimentary master-class because we believe the ritual is as important as the leaf.

Complimentary Master-Class

Join us in Balboa Island for a complimentary master-class. Learn what separates an elite wrapper, how to cut and light correctly, and how to recognize tasting notes with confidence. Walk out with a ritual you'll keep for life.

Wrapper & construction education

Tasting notes + pairing fundamentals

Proper cutting & lighting technique

Walk-ins welcome (RSVP optional)

About Us

Balboa Island Cigar Co. is a proudly women-owned business rooted in resilience, passion, and the spirit of creativity. Our journey began with Sheryl, the founder, who turned a personal challenge into the foundation for something extraordinary.

While caring for her mother during her battle with cancer, Sheryl sought a way to mask the unpleasant odors associated with her mother's condition. The solution came in the form of a carefully crafted candle, infused with the rich, comforting scent of cigars—something Sheryl had always loved. With the creation of "The Lady on the Horse," a photo of Sheryl on a horse smoking a cigar sparked the curiosity of her customers. They began asking where they could find the cigars, and Sheryl, never one to shy away from a challenge, knew she had to create something even more special.

Determined to offer something truly unique, Sheryl set off on a journey to Nicaragua to master the art of cigar blending. There, she worked with expert artisans to create the Balboa Island Reserve, a signature line of premium cigars that would rival the finest in the world. Our collection features four box-pressed Robusto cigars, each offering a distinct profile that ranges from mellow to full-bodied, and pairs perfectly with your favorite libation.

At Balboa Island Cigar Co., we believe in pushing boundaries, embracing challenges, and delivering an exceptional experience with every cigar. Whether you're a seasoned aficionado or a new enthusiast, our cigars offer a distinctive flavor journey that celebrates the craft, the tradition, and the passion behind every smoke.

Join us in savoring the moments that matter, one cigar at a time.

Visit

213 1/2 Marine Avenue
Balboa Island, California

Hours

Open Daily · 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Contact

(818) 231-0886

Parking

Street parking along Marine Avenue

Balboa Island Reserve premium cigar collection featuring four box-pressed robustos

The Journal

Occasional notes on wrapper selection, pairing principles, and the discipline of construction. No noise. Only signal.

Insights on wrapper selection, tasting notes, and the ritual.